Brian Kodi 2008-12-27
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
"The brain that changes itself" demonstrates the various ways the theoretical plasticity of the brain can produce significant recovery of patients suffering from the most debilitating ailments, including paralysis from stroke, and autism. Prior to the acceptance of the idea that the human brain is surprisingly flexible and adaptable (plastic), most neuroscientists were of the belief that different sections of the brain specialized in specific tasks (localization), and these specialized areas became rigid and solidified early on in life in such a way that sufficient damage to each section would forever deprive the victim of its functionality.
While Mr. Doidge presents numerous case studies detailing the astonishing and successful impact of plasticity based therapies, there is a peculiar absence of failed outcomes using these methods. As a result, just how far can plasticity take us is difficult to ascertain.
Unfortunately, Mr. Doidge's presentation portrays him as more a cheerleader than an objective source of information on neuroplasticity, and his excitement comes through as glaringly obvious. Consequently, his ideas have a deterministic flavor to them. Plasticity, as he implies, is the end all, be all remedy for a host of maladies, and then some.
Mr. Doidge is also unclear what the future applications of this relatively new field of brain study are. Seemingly, he believes plasticity of the brain can reverse or cure maladies in every walk of life, including but not limited to alzheimers, dementia, age related memory loss, Parkinson's, multiple sclerosis, arthritis, learning disabilities, worries, obsessions, compulsions, bad habits, stroke, and problems with sexual attraction and love. Clearly, some patients have benefited greatly from plasticity based therapies, but none of these aforementioned conditions have been close to being eradicated, which begs the question, just what is the potential of neuroplasticity? Can it benefit the plethora of conditions as described b y Mr. Doidge or is he grasping at straws in some cases?
Mr. Doidge's effort in writing this book is to be commended, as it simplifies the field of neuroplasticity and introduces its ground breaking ideas in a coherent and understandable manner to the masses with many interesting case studies. Beyond that, a more focused and less deterministic approach would have made this an outstanding piece of work worthy of five stars.