Hulka 2007-05-30
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful:
Fans of Vincent Karthieser will enjoy this movie and his portrayal of a sensitive young man dealing with a dysfunctional family in rural Idaho. But the movie doesn't rise to the dramatic quality of Kartheiser's other movies, "Crime and Punishment in Suburbia" or "The Unsaid", or his recent appearance in the TV series, "Angel".
This is probably the worst script Vincent's had to deal with since the terrible "Heaven Sent". Many of Vincent's roles border on the melodramatic, but this script goes over the top. Also, Kartheiser's co-star, Tara Manning is another mis-match for Kartheiser. The problem is not Manning, but the script. Manning is believable as the stereotypical poor white "trailer park" girl she is asked to play, it's unbelievable that a girl like that would find anything in common with the sensitive, quiet dreamer that Kartheiser plays.
Another problem is that roles like this are getting a bit repititious for Kartheiser, and this lousy script doesn't offer Kartheiser anything new to work with. I've been bewitched by Vincent Kartheiser's on-screen personae for a long time. Vincent's movies and TV roles have this re-occurring theme of sensitive loner (most suburban teenaged) boy struggling with teenage alienation and angst. Crime and Punishment in Suburbia, The Unsaid, TV series Angels...all the same thing. This script just seems to reinforce the stereotype, and poor Kartheiser can't rise above script and his performance comes off as a rip-off of earlier roles.
Another problem is that Kartheiser is getting a little "long in the tooth" to play roles like this. As Kartheiser gets older, he's losing the androgenous beauty that has fascinated viewers in the past, and we see the tell-tale facial hair that we've not seen before in his other movies. While Kartheiser still got the ability to move us with the sincerity and honesty of his portrayals of the alienated, tortured suburban teenage boy, at some point, he's got to move on to more adult roles.
Despite the defects, I felt it was still worth it to spend another 90 odd minutes with Vincent, and I think you'll feel the same!