MS JERSEY 2006-12-31

4 of 6 people found the following review helpful:

.....I REMEMBER WHEN MY GRANDMOTHER USE TO SIT US DOWN BRIGHT & EARLY

EVERY SUNDAY JUST TO READ THIS BIBLE...SO THAT WE CAN BETTER OVERSTAND

THE ADULT'S BIBLE! EVEN AS A CHILD THERE WERE CERTAIN STORIES THAT STUCK

WITH MORE SUCH AS:"RICH MAN POOR MAN", THE STORY OF LAZARUS, THE BOOK OF

MATTHEW WHEN satan CHALLENGED JESUS & JESUS SIMPLY SAID "GET THEE HENCE

satan"!WHOO IT GIVES ME CHILLS EVEN NOW! 1 REVIEWER WROTE THAT THE

PICTURES OF JONAH & THE WHALE WAS GRAPHIC & SCARY... WELL I THINK THAT WAS

THE POINT, A PICTURE SAYS A THOUSAND WORDS! I'M THANKFUL FOR THE IMAGES

CHILDREN CAN RELATE TO COLORFUL PICTURES, IT GETS THEIR ATTENTION (IT GOT

MINE) *I WILL BE PURCHASING THIS BIBLE AGAIN, I LOVE IT! OH & FOR THE

PARENTS THAT WANT TO EDUCATE YOUR CHILDREN ABOUT THE WORD, LET THEM SEE

"THE MIRACLE MAKER, THE STORY OF JESUS CHRIST"!!
______________________________BOTTOM LINE________________________________

Shopper in Richmond 2006-10-11

2 of 19 people found the following review helpful:

The Golden Children's Bible is recommended by some Catholic homeschooling curriculum providers. This children's book is supposedly a collaborative effort between Jewish, Catholic, and Protestant scholars. However, I did not see any evidence of input from the Catholic scholars. In skimming over the text, this seems to be a distinctly Protestant Bible. I noted a number of areas that would be problematic for Catholics:

The first red flag is the translation of Genesis 3:15. My Catholic (Douay-Rheims) Bible says:

"I will put enmities between thee and the woman, and thy seed and her seed: she shall crush thy head, and thou shalt lie in wait for her heel."

The reference is to Mary, the new Eve, and the symbolism is a rich and important part of our faith. Think of Our Lady of Grace crushing the snake with her heel. I love that image! Now in the Golden Children' Bible it says:

"I shall make the woman your enemy and her children the enemies of your children. They shall wound you in the head and you shall wound them in the heel."

It just doesn't have the force (or fidelity) of Mary crushing the head of the snake. It loses all of the symbolism of Mary as the new Eve. Eve brought sin into our lives by yielding to the snake, whereas Mary carried our Salvation in her womb and hence through her yielding to God's will she metaphorically stomped on the head of the snake (which symbolizes evil).

Another red flag is the beginning of St. Luke, where the Archangel Gabriel appears to Mary. In the Golden Children's Bible the angel says, not "Hail, full of grace," but rather, "Hail, most favored one." Again, a seemingly small change, but it makes a big difference as to whether children can discern that the opening words to the Hail Mary came from this passage. It also diminishes the teaching that Mary was not just most favored among women, but literally full of God's grace.

Next, in Matthew 6 where Our Lord teaches us to pray, the Golden Children's Bible tacks on a doxology to the end of the Our Father, so that their version of the prayer ends with "For thine is the kingdom, and the power, and the glory, for ever. Amen." This is putting words into Our Lord's mouth that He did not say. Catholics do not add these words to the Our Father. This is not how we pray.

So, two of our most important prayers, taken right out of the Bible, are distorted in this text. What message does this give our children?

These errors were enough for me to rule out this text. There might be more errors contained within; I did not feel I needed to read more. There are lots of pretty pictures and it's a huge book, but it's not worth exposing children to the errors. Children should be able to trust that their "Bible stories" should contain only truth. I don't know why anybody would recommend this book for Catholic children. There are better choices.

cherokeegenie 2006-09-27

6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:

I was given one of these as a young girl many years ago, and still enjoy reading it as an adult.
The artwork is wonderful, and the text easy to read and understand..I highly recommend it as beginning reading or listening for young people and a gift that will be cherished through the years.

K. Forsythe 2006-04-22

0 of 4 people found the following review helpful:

When I was a little girl, my grandmother used to read me bedtime stories out of this book, a favorite of mine was the story of King Solomn. To this day I remember all of the feelings that I had as a child when my grandmother read this book to me. She passed away several years ago, but I talk to her in my prayers and thank her for teaching me the value of reading, of which this book was a big part in.