Sandy M. 2008-09-07

0 of 2 people found the following review helpful:

Like C. S. Lewis's Narnia this is one story everyone should read at least once in their life. If you are looking for a good read or listen, I don't see how you can go wrong with this one. I started reading this series because my library carries the books on Playaway and it was recommended to me by a librarian as "an entertaining, well-written fantasy story for all ages." I also learned the book was highly recommended by Voya and is something of a pop phenom as it is also mentioned in "Complete Idiots Guide to Elves and Fairies" and "Ancient Art of Fairy Magick".

I listened to the first two books and the audio was so wonderful I decided to buy the entire series. Like the audio, the books are of exceptional quality with its dozens of full-page illustrations and illustrated end notes.

This third book continues the adventures of Vilmos, Adrina, Emel and Seth. In this book, Adrina returns home to Imtal after a long time away. She has a heavy burden and is having a difficult time dealing with what happened. Vilmos and Xith leave the south and begin a new journey that takes them to the mouth of the world and places beyond. Emel journeys north to Imtal with the garrison and worries about what's to come. The turmoil has shattered ancient alliances and the ancient evil is growing stronger.

This is the only series I've ever read where I had so many favorite characters. Robert Stanek is an incredibly gifted writer with a true talent for writing believable characters and bringing new worlds to life. He gives enough details to see everything that's going on but not so much to slow the story. The dialogue continues to be excellent as well and it's one of the reasons the story works so well in audio.

I highly recommend The Kingdoms and the Elves of the Reaches III (Reader's Choice Edition, Keeper Martin's Tales Book 3) (Keeper Martin's Tales) but don't miss The Kingdoms and the Elves of the Reaches (Reader's Choice Edition, Keeper Martin's Tales Book 1) (Keeper Martin's Tales). You need to start with the first one to understand the story. I also recommend The Kingdoms and the Elves of the Reaches II (Reader's Choice Edition, Keeper Martin's Tales Book 2) (Keeper Martin's Tales) and The Kingdoms and the Elves of the Reaches IV (Reader's Choice Edition, Keeper Martin's Tales Book 4) (Keeper Martin's Tales).

Donna W. 2008-08-24

0 of 2 people found the following review helpful:

Another amazingly written book by Robert Stanek. He is, in my opinion, the best writer. His writing gives you so much detail, you just keep coming back for more. The main characters in the story are Adrina, Vilmos, Seth, Emel and Xith. In this book, they are dealing with shock from the recent battles and the shattering of a long peace. Adrina makes a big decision about her future. Emel returns thinking he has failed. Vilmos continues his wizard training with Xith. The details in the book make you use your imagination. Each book keeps you on the edge of your seat, wanting more and more. It's great for all ages!

P. Gunelson 2008-05-07

11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:

My 14 yr. old son is a huge fan of the Kingdoms books and I must admit I am too. Robert Stanek is indeed America's Tolkien, a gifted story-teller with a knack for creating believable worlds and fully-realized characters. Many of the characters become like old friends and even the minor characters truly are interesting and real. The story itself is detailed and rich but Stanek doesn't allow the action to slow, keeping everything moving at a solid pace.

The Kingdoms and the Elves of the Reaches #3 continues where the first two left off. The kingdomers begin to pick up the pieces of their lives after the battles at Quashan and Alderan broke the uneasy peace between the kingdoms. A new force continues to emerge from the shadows even as the evil king and the shapeshifting queen are being dealt with.

Very highly recommended and you'll want to have all four books on hand.

2007-04-27

7 of 9 people found the following review helpful:

I started reading The Kingdoms books since me brothers were reading them too. Adrina and Vilmos are my favorites. In my mind I see Adrina and Vilmos growing up like I imagined and they are very good friends to have on rainy days. I like these books but than all the Harry Potter books put together times 100. I like this one best as it is the one where Vilmos meets Edward the troant and its got the Dragon King!!! I love everything about the king's mate game and how edward is half troll and half giatn.

2007-02-16

9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:

This book was amazing. I was so involede in it that when I went to school all I could think of was Vilmos, Emel, Seth and Adrina. When I went to sleep I had dreams about them. This book is far better than Harry Potter , a real page turner. I reccomend this book to all.